Work out who hosts the mailbox, then ask them for the right kind of password.
Nevermore signs in over plain IMAP with an app-specific password — a separate, revocable password that works for one app and nothing else. Almost every mail host that supports IMAP can issue one; what they call it and where they keep it varies, and we can only describe the ones we have checked.
A custom domain does not tell you. The address you@yourcompany.com
might be hosted by Google Workspace, iCloud, Fastmail, or your web host's own
mail server, and the app password lives with whoever runs the mailbox — not
with whoever sold you the domain.
We have not verified any particular host's screens, so rather than describe a menu that may not exist: look in your webmail's account or security settings for a section about app passwords, application-specific passwords, device passwords, or third-party apps. If your host offers none of those, an IMAP client typically signs in with your normal mailbox password instead — that is common on smaller hosts and works fine with Nevermore.
If you can't find any of it, your host's support can tell you in one reply: ask whether the mailbox allows IMAP access, and whether it needs an app-specific password.
When Nevermore doesn't recognise your domain it asks you to choose a provider. That choice sets which IMAP server it connects to, so pick whoever hosts the mailbox — Gmail for a Google Workspace domain, and so on. It is not a guess about your address.
Paste it into the App password field on Nevermore's sign-in screen. Spaces are fine — the app strips them. It goes straight into the macOS Keychain, is never written to disk in the clear, and never leaves your Mac.
Checked against each provider's documentation on 22 August 2026. Providers move these settings without warning; if what you see does not match, their page is the authoritative one and we would be glad to hear about it.